I hated doing it. I've never pulled the curtain down in the middle of an act, but it wasn't working. I wasn't happy. On paper, it sounds like everything should have been fine, but it wasn't. We met once before and had dinner together. It was fine. I wasn't feeling the sparks, but we had a lot of the same kinks in common and he was nice. Maybe the sparks would come later…
I tried to be in the moment, but it was not happening. His kisses were odd, his touch was off, I felt no connection, but I figured I just needed to get into the mood. It was our first time together, he wasn't used to my body. I wasn't used to his teeth. He pulled off my my top and unbuttoned my jeans slipping his fingers into my underwear. He slipped a finger into my cunt, a bit surprised that I was so wet already. I was, too. My twat has a mind of her own.
He pulled off his shirt and stood above me as I sat on the couch. He pulled down his underwear and I went down to suck his cock. Soon there was a long string of drool coating my chest. He was long and thick. I went down to the balls, taking it down my throat, running my tongue along his cock. He grabbed my head and started to fuck my mouth. It is rare that a cock in my mouth and a hand on the back of my head does not relax me, but something was off.
He sat back on the couch and I laid across his lap. He reached around and slipped his fingers in my cunt and pulled, forcing me upwards. He slipped in another finger and fiercely fucked me, hitting my G spot and flicking my clit with his thumb. I closed my eyes and concentrated on the grinding. I was not thinking about him, but I came twice, clutching my thighs together, trapping his hand inside me. He asked me what I was thinking about. I pointed at his cock and nodded at my cunt. "That, in here."
But first a little flogging. He had mentioned that he was big into florentine. I had my doubts. It looks too fancy for me. A lot of perfume, but not a lot of substance. But I was willing to give it a shot. It was erratic feeling, and oddly stingy. It created a breeze. It was like getting scratched, more than hit. I think it probably looks better than it feels. I was relieved when he grabbed me by the neck and led me to the bedroom. I sucked his cock for a while, then he took my head in his hands and started massaging my face. It was weird. Then he slapped the side of my face, then the other side. Again, there was nothing bad about this in and of itself, but there was just something about it that felt… off. He pulled out a condom and then excused himself for a moment. He came back with a cock ring and put it on. I've never been with a guy with a cock ring. I didn't know if it was a good thing or a bad thing.
But his cock felt right. I started on my back, resting my legs on his shoulders. It started off with that comfortable fullness, slowly easing in and out. Again, I closed my eyes, trying to go with the flow. He leaned into kiss me and I accepted it for a moment before turning my head to the side and offering my neck instead. Soon he started banging away. He moved my left leg over around him so he was fucking me from the side. This was even better. He could get in deeper and the angle was hitting me just right. He came at me hard and fast, and I demanded harder and faster, pushing my hands against the wall to force myself back on to him. My pussy was there, but my head was not. I was not happy and I didn't know why.
Then the ear thing. I've been having some weird ear thing lately. My right ear will plug up for no apparent reason. It's really annoying. He's banging away at my cunt and my ear pops. It's really, really annoying. I had to stop. I did all the tricks you do when your ear pops and it wasn't working. Then suddenly he slapped the left side of my face. My left ear immediately started ringing. "What the fuck!?" I said, pissed. He thought it would help. It didn't. Now, instead of one fucked up ear to deal with I had two. I thought, with some people, that might have just made me laugh. I would shake my head, lay back down and spread my legs. Not this time. "I'm sorry, but I don't think it's going to happen."
I know it was confusing. He said, "But you were so into it." It may have seemed that way, but I wasn't. Not really. I would rather be honest than pretend to feel something I didn't. I don't fake orgasms, either. It's not fair to anyone. This had never happened to him before. Honestly, I've never done it before. I used to just take it. Go through the motions with someone I wasn't into, afraid of being disappointing. So I would wait until he came and left and I would feel like shit. Well, fuck that.
He's not used to rejection and I hate to bruise an ego. We talked a little and he was surprisingly understanding. He said, I looked sad and I suppose I was a little. I don't know what happened and why, but I do know if something doesn't feel right, don't do it. I didn't want to lie to him. Is it possible to look passionate and not feel it? How can my body betray my mind like that? He did say that I sucked cock like a gay man which I take to be a good thing.